Is a Negative × a Negative a Positive? The Complete Explanation
Short answer: yes. Consider this: when you multiply or divide two negative numbers, the result is always positive. So (−3) × (−4) = 12, and (−20) ÷ (−5) = 4. But the real question most students are asking is why — and that answer is what turns a memorized rule into real understanding Worth knowing..
The Short Answer First
| Operation | Example | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Negative × Negative | (−3) × (−4) | +12 |
| Negative × Positive | (−3) × 4 | −12 |
| Positive × Negative | 3 × (−4) | −12 |
| Positive × Positive | 3 × 4 | +12 |
| Negative ÷ Negative | (−20) ÷ (−5) | +4 |
| Negative ÷ Positive | (−20) ÷ 5 | −4 |
The pattern is simple: same signs give a positive, different signs give a negative. That rule works for multiplication and division, always.
Why It Works: The Pattern Argument
The easiest way to see it is to watch a pattern continue.
Look at what happens as the second factor drops by 1 each time:
- (−3) × 3 = −9
- (−3) × 2 = −6
- (−3) × 1 = −3
- (−3) × 0 = 0
- (−3) × (−1) = ?
Every time the second number decreases by 1, the product increases by 3. Following the pattern, the next answer must be +3. Keep going and it keeps working:
- (−3) × (−2) = 6
- (−3) × (−3) = 9
Mathematics is deeply consistent. Rules are not invented arbitrarily — they are chosen so that patterns like this never break And that's really what it comes down to..
Why It Works: The Proof Using the Distributive Property
If you want something more rigorous, here is a clean proof using the distributive property, which says that a × (b + c) = ab + ac.
Start with the fact that any number plus its opposite equals zero:
3 + (−3) = 0
Now multiply both sides by −2:
(−2) × [3 + (−3)] = (−2) × 0
Distribute the −2:
(−2)(3) + (−2)(−3) = 0
We already know (−2)(3) = −6, so:
−6 + (−2)(−3) = 0
The only number that can be added to −6 to produce 0 is +6. Therefore:
(−2)(−3) = 6
This is not a convention someone chose for fun. It is forced by the requirement that arithmetic stays logically consistent. If negative × negative were negative, the distributive property itself would collapse, and almost all of algebra would stop working.
Why It Works: The Number Line and "Reversing Direction"
Multiplication by a positive number stretches a number line. Multiplication by a negative number does something extra: it flips it to the opposite side of zero Still holds up..
- 3 × 2 means "face right, walk forward twice" → +6
- (−3) × 2 means "face left, walk forward twice" → −6
- 3 × (−2) means "face right, but walk backwards twice" → −6
- (−3) × (−2) means "face left, then walk backwards twice" → you end up on the right side → +6
Two reversals cancel each other out. That is the heart of the rule: a negative sign is a direction flip, and flipping twice returns you to the start.
Real-World Analogies That Make It Stick
Debt and cancellation. Suppose you cancel a debt of $5, three times. Canceling a debt is good news, so removing −$5 three times is a gain: (−3) × (−5) = +15 Still holds up..
Video playback. Rewinding a video of someone walking backwards makes them appear to walk forwards. Two "reversals" produce forward motion.
Temperature change. A cooling rate of −3 degrees per hour, applied for −2 hours (that is, 2 hours ago), means the temperature was 6 degrees higher in the past Nothing fancy..
These analogies are not proofs, but they help the rule feel less like magic.
The Rule for Division
Division is just multiplication in disguise, so the same sign rules apply exactly:
- (−24) ÷ (−6) = 4
- (−24) ÷ 6 = −4
- 24 ÷ (−6) = −4
Ask yourself: "What number times the divisor gives the dividend?" For (−24) ÷ (−6), you need a number that, multiplied by −6, gives −24. That number is +4.
Multiple Negatives: Count the Signs
When several negative numbers are multiplied together, count the negative signs:
- Even number of negatives → positive result (−2) × (−3) × (−1) × (−4) = 24 (four negatives)
- Odd number of negatives → negative result (−2) × (−3) × (−1) = −6 (three negatives)
This is the same reason (−1)ⁿ is positive when n is even and negative when n is odd Turns out it matters..
The Big Confusion to Avoid
Multiplication is not addition. This is where most mistakes happen And that's really what it comes down to..
- (−3) + (−5) = −8 (adding two negatives stays negative)
- (−3) × (−5) = +15 (multiplying two negatives flips to positive)
Also watch these traps:
- Exponents: (−3)² = 9, but −3² = −9. Parentheses decide whether the negative sign is part of the base.
- Subtraction: 5 − (−3) = 5 + 3 = 8. Subtracting a negative is adding a positive.
- Mixed operations: handle signs step by step rather than guessing.